Preservation and architectural integrity: the dilemma of how to best treat the context of an historic building during redevelopment

Abstract

This report is about the dilemma of how to best treat the context of an historic building during redevelopment, and is based on the hypothesis 'Architectural integrity, innovation, and opportunity are key considerations to successful preservation and building redevelopment'. The comparison of Wellington CBD redevelopments Kirkcaldie and Stains and The Majestic Centre demonstrate the importance of maintaining the integrity of the original building. The Wellington City Council's Proposed District Plan identifies the values or level of significance of heritage buildings, and reinforces the need for authenticity of the architectural intervention as a major determinant of their ongoing significance. Opportunity and innovation have ensured the original buildings now have a justified role; the past is usable and it helps define the identity of the nation.